Oil spill response doesn’t address issue
Every day, an international audience is reminded of the oil crisis in the Gulf of Mexico. BP estimates that spillage is 100,000 barrels (15.9 million litres) per day.
The BP oil crisis is an economic and ecological nightmare with no easy solutions on the horizon.
However, the true crisis is less about oil, and more about the social permissibility of our so-called green consumerism.
The media’s round the clock coverage of the spill deflects our collective responsibility onto the usual suspects: the White House and BP shareholders.
The paradox is that, even though Obama cannot stop the oil from gushing, his search for someone’s ass to kick might be an effective solution because it de-politicizes the looming crisis of peak oil. The present oil crisis is not simply signaling an ecological crisis, inadequate administrative oversight, the multiple risks associated with oil extraction, and the greed of BP shareholders. The present oil crisis in the Gulf of Mexico signals a terminal crisis in global capitalism. In the popular media, very little has been done to connect this oil crisis to the crisis of peak oil.
Popular media appeals to the naïve ideological desires of an international audience. It unites us in collective moral outrage thereby perpetuating the false belief that any White House administration could solve all problems emerging in the Gulf of Mexico.
Effectively, the crisis of peak oil is de-politicized through popular media coverage of short-term solutions to the incalculable ecological and financial losses accrued. The media is the unofficial accomplice to the officially labeled scapegoats.
Without the help of the popular press, BP and the Obama administration could not use the present crisis in the Gulf of Mexico to re-establish a basic trust in global capitalism lost in the first decade of the new century.
The easy moralistic game of finger pointing used by the popular press is a tactic that creates a false belief that a real plan of action looms offshore.
Surely Obama must show public concern about the immediate consequences of this disaster and BP shareholders must be made financially liable. However, it is dangerous to disconnect the acute oil crisis in the Gulf of Mexico from the peak oil crisis looming on the horizon, and even more dangerous to assume that the worst has already come to pass.
It is possible that the oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico is merely the tip of an iceberg. Just as the effects of the present crisis in the Gulf of Mexico will only be understood in hindsight, the point when the maximum rate of global petroleum extraction is reached will only be known in hindsight.
However, the oil crisis in the Gulf of Mexico cannot be linked to the crisis of peak oil if we do not recognize that global capitalism is in a state of terminal crisis.
The Obama administration’s response to the ongoing oil crisis in the Gulf of Mexico highlights the coming crisis of peak oil: a crisis that has no easy solutions under the parameters of capitalism or democracy.


10 Comments
The Martlet has an open comments policy and will endeavour to promote healthy discussion. We strive to act as an agent of constructive social change and will remove racist, sexist, homophobic, or otherwise oppressive comments.
Leave a Comment
Zev Paiss July 8, 2010, 11:12 a.m.
I agree that the current response may deflect from the Peak Oil issue, but the very fact that BP and other are drilling in 5,000 feet of water confirms the Peak Oil issue. Why would any company take on these risks if they saw another option. The easy oil is gone (except i Iraq but that is another story) and we are only going to see more problems like the Gulf spill in the years to come.
Zev Paiss July 8, 2010, 11:12 a.m.
I agree that the current response may deflect from the Peak Oil issue, but the very fact that BP and other are drilling in 5,000 feet of water confirms the Peak Oil issue. Why would any company take on these risks if they saw another option. The easy oil is gone (except i Iraq but that is another story) and we are only going to see more problems like the Gulf spill in the years to come.
Ben July 8, 2010, 10:51 p.m.
Deep sea oil can't last too long, it is too dangerous and tough to get at. The danger and difficulty level is about at the same level as space exploration. Perhaps more as the pressure ten thousand feet down is absolutely crushing. And besides passive solar rays, we actively get no resources from space.
We have ocean tourism on the surface, we don't even have space tourism yet because it is far too dangerous. Yes, deep water oil is a very short term solution. It is doomed.
Peak oil just got closer it seems.
Ben July 8, 2010, 10:51 p.m.
Deep sea oil can't last too long, it is too dangerous and tough to get at. The danger and difficulty level is about at the same level as space exploration. Perhaps more as the pressure ten thousand feet down is absolutely crushing. And besides passive solar rays, we actively get no resources from space.
We have ocean tourism on the surface, we don't even have space tourism yet because it is far too dangerous. Yes, deep water oil is a very short term solution. It is doomed.
Peak oil just got closer it seems.
Rojelio July 9, 2010, 2:53 a.m.
I've found that is is difficult to engage people in any sort of discussion about how the financial meltdown in 2008 was inextricably linked to intolerably high oil prices. There seems to be virtually no awareness of this relationship in any sector of society. Sorely lacking in the mainstream media is a concise, straightforward explanation of how oil prices affect Wall Street. Even the recent 2009 Frontline documentary, which did a moderately good job of explaining our tendency towards preposterous amounts of debt, never mentioned oil once in their commentary.
Rojelio July 9, 2010, 2:53 a.m.
I've found that is is difficult to engage people in any sort of discussion about how the financial meltdown in 2008 was inextricably linked to intolerably high oil prices. There seems to be virtually no awareness of this relationship in any sector of society. Sorely lacking in the mainstream media is a concise, straightforward explanation of how oil prices affect Wall Street. Even the recent 2009 Frontline documentary, which did a moderately good job of explaining our tendency towards preposterous amounts of debt, never mentioned oil once in their commentary.
Graham Mewburn July 9, 2010, 5:39 a.m.
What about food? An oil crisis = a food crisis. URGENT! Buy locally grown food. When the trucks stop coming, where will you get your food? Gray Graham Mewburn Australia
Graham Mewburn July 9, 2010, 5:39 a.m.
What about food? An oil crisis = a food crisis. URGENT! Buy locally grown food. When the trucks stop coming, where will you get your food? Gray Graham Mewburn Australia
Peak Oil July 13, 2010, 11:12 a.m.
How can you say this when capitalism is one of the main reasons driving innovators to create green technology.
Electric cars are coming down in price fast and becoming more and more feasible. Solar panels are getting better and cheaper. When peak oil finally starts to show itself, it won't really matter since we'd have plenty of alternatives lined up.
Ineffective environmentalists aren't going to save the world from peak oil nor global warming. The real saviours are the innovators with the entrenpreneuring spirit that makes capitalism so great.
Peak Oil July 13, 2010, 11:12 a.m.
How can you say this when capitalism is one of the main reasons driving innovators to create green technology.
Electric cars are coming down in price fast and becoming more and more feasible. Solar panels are getting better and cheaper. When peak oil finally starts to show itself, it won't really matter since we'd have plenty of alternatives lined up.
Ineffective environmentalists aren't going to save the world from peak oil nor global warming. The real saviours are the innovators with the entrenpreneuring spirit that makes capitalism so great.