The end of Harper’s conservative rule
After January’s load-blowing, deficit-spending budget, conservative pundits are furiously harping on about Prime Minister Stephen Harper’s betrayals of conservative dogma — he might as well be a Liberal for all they care.
At least back in the day when Brian Mulroney was PM, he could be excused for flip-flopping this way. But Harper? His career was born out of the anger that “true” conservatives from the Reform and Canadian Alliance Parties felt toward Mulroney. In their minds, Mulroney screwed up so badly that it destroyed his party and ushered in almost a decade and a half of Liberal rule.
Harper used to be the evangelical poster boy for the most “admirable” of conservative stances — restricting immigrants from transforming Canadian culture, reforming the Senate, free votes for MPs, supporting the U.S. invasion of Iraq — to name but a few.
And then he won his first election, albeit with a minority in Parliament. Out the window went the rhetoric about gay marriage. Talk about revisiting the abortion issue was hushed.
Now Harper has appointed Senators en masse, kicked MPs out of his party for voting their conscience, challenged the U.S. foreign policy on the Arctic and gone on a deficit spending spree to save Canadian jobs — most notably his.
So is the Right Honourable Stephen Harper now a Liberal? When you size up the new Liberal leader, Michael Ignatieff, you get the sense he and Harper could’ve been buds in another life.
Harper’s duplicitous talk about balanced budgets, no recession and finding deals on the stock market sure doesn’t sound like the maverick-esque straight talk you’d expect from such a clean-cut heir to the conservative movement’s throne — just another reason to conclude that Harper is a fraud, deluded and seduced by attaining and retaining power in Ottawa.
“The West Wants In” used to be Harper’s rallying cry. When he won the election in 2006, he declared his own version of “Mission Accomplished.” Now that his pal George W. Bush is soaking up the sun, clearing brush on a ranch somewhere deep in the heart of Texas, Harper and his western “conservatism” are all alone — the Coalition of the Willing’s last bastion of pseudo-conservatism that Bailout Bush’s last acts as President exposed as hollow.
Clearly, this all points to Harper being the wily strategist all his subordinates once feared him for: if at first your ideals don’t succeed, try the opposite, try again.
This is Canada of course, glorious and free — home of legalized gay marriage, ethnic inclusiveness and universal health care.
Harper can deport American war resisters and ignore climate change all he wants to pay lip-service to conservatism, but he’s gradually becoming just another pebble on the banks of the Ottawa River — subject to the forces of erosion that Canada’s cherished progressive identity has on hard-hearted conservatism.


4 Comments
The Martlet has an open comments policy and will endeavour to promote healthy discussion. We strive to act as an agent of constructive social change and will remove racist, sexist, homophobic, or otherwise oppressive comments.
Leave a Comment
Steve Feb. 12, 2009, 12:14 p.m.
Canada is truly in a sad state of affairs. The difference between liberal and conservative is so blurred that it hardly has any meaning in the American sense of the words. Consider a couple of obvious differences between America and Canada:
supporting gay marriage is still a radical position even for a national Democrat to take in the US and even a majority of voters in a left-leaning state like California don't want it, but in Canada opposing gay marriage is a radical position that even most 'conservatives' shy from.
laws on prostitution in Canada are laughably liberal as it's legal in the whole country as are swinger clubs, etc, etc. In the US, only some counties in Nevada allow it and even the ultra-liberal City of San Francisco has twice voted (by large majorities) to reject attempts to de-criminalize prostitution.
the death penalty has long been outlawed in Canada but in the US it remains the law of the land in the vast majority of states, including many very liberal ones.
The list goes on and those are just the social issues. I can hardly imagine anything more dis-heartening than being a true Canadian conservative in this day and age.
Steve Feb. 12, 2009, 12:14 p.m.
Canada is truly in a sad state of affairs. The difference between liberal and conservative is so blurred that it hardly has any meaning in the American sense of the words. Consider a couple of obvious differences between America and Canada:
supporting gay marriage is still a radical position even for a national Democrat to take in the US and even a majority of voters in a left-leaning state like California don't want it, but in Canada opposing gay marriage is a radical position that even most 'conservatives' shy from.
laws on prostitution in Canada are laughably liberal as it's legal in the whole country as are swinger clubs, etc, etc. In the US, only some counties in Nevada allow it and even the ultra-liberal City of San Francisco has twice voted (by large majorities) to reject attempts to de-criminalize prostitution.
the death penalty has long been outlawed in Canada but in the US it remains the law of the land in the vast majority of states, including many very liberal ones.
The list goes on and those are just the social issues. I can hardly imagine anything more dis-heartening than being a true Canadian conservative in this day and age.
Eric R Biddle Feb. 13, 2009, 2:08 a.m.
Harper the hapless and his harpies are driving at high speed Canada into depression the worst since the 20s and his neglect of the legal system is and international disgrace and abomination here in Europe especially and Finland in particular where Eric R Biddle born in Vancouver 28.02.50 is safe and free at last. Take a look at Eric R Biddle with TV Ontario investigative documentary online. It is because of media censorship in our totalitarian police state of Canada and Harper that Eric R Biddle cannot get media coverage. He refused the demand of Harper to return to Canada for him to decide his Judicial review and necessarity compensate him about 12 million euros. Eric does not want to defect to the intelligence services of Russia but he will if Harper does not fork up 1 million this year.
Eric R Biddle Feb. 13, 2009, 2:08 a.m.
Harper the hapless and his harpies are driving at high speed Canada into depression the worst since the 20s and his neglect of the legal system is and international disgrace and abomination here in Europe especially and Finland in particular where Eric R Biddle born in Vancouver 28.02.50 is safe and free at last. Take a look at Eric R Biddle with TV Ontario investigative documentary online. It is because of media censorship in our totalitarian police state of Canada and Harper that Eric R Biddle cannot get media coverage. He refused the demand of Harper to return to Canada for him to decide his Judicial review and necessarity compensate him about 12 million euros. Eric does not want to defect to the intelligence services of Russia but he will if Harper does not fork up 1 million this year.